essay
written on 23-04-2023
Should prisoners be allowed to vote?
Prisoners are individuals that have committed crimes and have been found guilty by the court of law. One of the fundamental rights in a democratic society is the right to vote; it is a symbol of the freedom that democratic societies promote. However, the situation for prisoners is different. They have been removed from society for their criminal activities, and their rights are restricted. This raises the question of whether prisoners should be allowed to vote.
Many countries have different opinions on prisoners voting rights. In some countries, prisoners' voting rights are entirely denied, while in others, prisoners can vote under certain conditions. For instance, in the United States, some states allow prisoners to vote, while others do not. Furthermore, in Europe, Sweden and Finland allow the majority of prisoners to vote, while others have more restrictive policies.
One of the main arguments presented against allowing prisoners to vote is that they have forfeited their rights by violating the social contract. The proponents argue that prisoners have broken the law, and therefore they should not have the right to participate in the political process. They believe that, by committing a crime, prisoners have betrayed the society, and hence, should not be allowed to exercise their democratic rights.
However, the proponents of prisoners' voting rights argue that withholding the right to vote from prisoners can have negative consequences. They advocate that voting is a fundamental and inherent human right and should not be denied to any citizen, including prisoners. Moreover, they argue that if prisoners are allowed to vote, it can help to foster a sense of civic responsibility and can lead to their rehabilitation and reintegration into society.
On the other hand, allowing prisoners to vote poses a significant challenge in terms of logistics. One challenge is ensuring that prisons can provide the necessary paperwork and infrastructure for prisoners to cast their votes. Additionally, allowing prisoners to vote raises a question concerning ethical considerations, whether prisoners are capable of making informed decisions.
In conclusion, the issue of prisoners' voting rights remains controversial. Denying prisoners the right to vote could further isolate them from society, but granting them this right could be seen as rewarding bad behaviour. However, denying prisoners the right to vote also means that they lose their political voice, which is a fundamental aspect of any democratic society. Therefore, a balance needs to be struck between the rehabilitation of the prisoners and the preservation of the democratic principles of society.